Lowering Your Risk Shouldn’t Mean Losing Feeling: Prophylactic Mastectomy and Sensation

Patient reviewing a 3D breast simulation during a prophylactic mastectomy consultation

Lowering Your Risk Shouldn’t Mean Losing Feeling: Prophylactic Mastectomy and Sensation

National Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer Week runs September 27 to October 3 this year, right at the start of Breast Cancer Awareness Month. It’s a week for anyone who has learned they carry a BRCA mutation or another genetic mutation, or who has watched breast cancer move through their family and wondered what it means for them.

We hear the same thing from so many of these patients. They were told a prophylactic mastectomy could protect their future, and in the same breath they were told to expect numb breasts afterward. As if lowering your risk and keeping feeling in your body were a trade you had to make. Today, for many people, it doesn’t have to be.

Dr. Peled spoke about this shift in a recent Women’s Health feature on young women choosing preventive double mastectomies. The article describes her as a surgeon who performs around 150 preventive mastectomies each year, and she shared what she is seeing in her own practice: “There’s a lot more emphasis these days on people getting cancer at younger ages.”

What a Hereditary Risk Really Means

Most breast cancers are not inherited. The American Cancer Society estimates that about 5% to 10% are linked to gene changes passed down in families. For people who do carry one of these changes, though, the numbers look very different.

According to the National Cancer Institute, about 55% to 72% of women with a harmful BRCA1 variant and about 45% to 69% of women with a harmful BRCA2 variant will develop breast cancer by age 70 to 80. That compares with about 13% of women in the general population. Other genes, like PALB2, CHEK2 and ATM, can raise risk as well.

Genetic testing and counseling can help you understand where you stand. A positive result is not a diagnosis. It’s information, and it gives you time to think about what you want.

Women’s Health reports that a growing number of young women who learn they are high risk, many of whom call themselves “previvors,” are now looking into prophylactic mastectomy in their 20s and early 30s, as breast cancer rates rise among women under 50. Dr. Peled sees how heavy that knowledge can feel. “I try to bring down the fear, because I do think it’s really scary right now,” she told the magazine.

Your Options When You Carry a Gene Change

There is no single right path, and every choice here is personal. As Dr. Peled told Women’s Health, “We’re in a time where people are trying to be more proactive about their health.” Being proactive looks different for everyone. In her words, “That may mean doing genetic testing. That may mean understanding family history better. That may mean getting breast cancer screening tests done earlier and more frequently if you’re high-risk.”

The most common options include:

  • Enhanced screening. Yearly mammograms and breast MRIs, often starting earlier than usual, to catch changes as soon as possible.
  • Medications. Some people take risk-reducing medicines, depending on their history and preferences.
  • Prophylactic mastectomy. Surgery to remove healthy breast tissue before cancer has a chance to develop.

For people with a BRCA mutation, the National Cancer Institute reports that a risk-reducing (prophylactic) mastectomy lowers the chance of developing breast cancer by about 90% to 95%. It is one of the most powerful tools available, and it’s also a big decision. Many people take months or even years to decide, and that’s okay. It’s also not the right choice for everyone.

The Question Too Few Patients Get Asked

For a long time, the conversation about prophylactic mastectomy stopped at risk. Feeling was rarely part of it.

With a traditional mastectomy, the nerves that give the breast and nipple sensation are cut. Research shows that only about 29% of patients keep any nipple sensation after a nipple-sparing mastectomy without nerve reconstruction (meta-analysis, 2022). Many describe a chest that feels numb for years, and that loss can affect comfort, intimacy and how at home they feel in their own body.

For someone who is healthy today and choosing surgery to stay that way, this matters a great deal. You deserve to know every option before you decide, including the option to keep feeling.

Prophylactic Mastectomy With Sensation Preservation

A sensation-preserving mastectomy is a nipple-sparing mastectomy combined with nerve preservation and nerve reconstruction. During surgery, the nerves that supply feeling to the breast and nipple are carefully identified. Whenever possible if oncologically safe they are kept intact. When a nerve has to be divided, it is reconnected using a nerve graft (a small segment of donor nerve that acts as a bridge) so it can regrow toward the nipple.

Dr. Peled and Dr. Ziv Peled, a peripheral nerve surgeon, began performing this approach together in 2018. Women’s Health described this work as part of a bigger change in reconstruction, noting that surgeons like Dr. Peled “have pioneered techniques for preserving and reconstructing nerves in the breast that would typically be cut during a mastectomy, allowing women to retain sensation in their breasts.” Since 2018 it has become the focus of our practice’s work, and results have been shared in peer-reviewed journals:

  • In a 2025 study, 74% of patients returned to their baseline nipple sensation within one year (Annals of Plastic Surgery, 2025).
  • Across eight years of outcomes, more than 80% of our patients regain near-baseline sensation, compared with fewer than 25% after a standard mastectomy.

Sensation returns gradually as nerves heal, often over several months to a year. Results vary from person to person, and not everyone is a candidate. That’s why a consultation is always the first step.

Choosing Protection Without Giving Something Up

A prophylactic mastectomy is an elective choice, and that gives you something valuable: time to plan. You can research surgeons, ask questions and look for a team that offers nerve preservation alongside reconstruction.

What we want every patient to know is that you can now pursue all of these goals together. Lower risk. Natural-looking reconstruction. Feeling in your breasts and nipples. You shouldn’t have to give up one to have the others.

The Women’s Health story includes one of our patients, a woman with a strong family history who found Dr. Peled through a friend. She had a nipple-preserving double mastectomy in 2020 and kept almost full sensation in her chest and nipples. Six years later, she often forgets she had a mastectomy at all. “You can have a full life,” she told the magazine.

Insurance has also caught up. As of April 2026, every major U.S. insurer covers nerve repair as part of breast reconstruction, a change that took years of advocacy to reach. You can read more in our ASBrS 2026 recap.

Questions to Ask Before a Prophylactic Mastectomy

If you’re considering a prophylactic mastectomy, these questions can help guide the conversation:

  • Am I a candidate for a nipple-sparing mastectomy?
  • Do you offer nerve preservation or nerve reconstruction?
  • What kind of sensation should I expect afterward, and on what timeline?
  • Which reconstruction options fit my body and goals?
  • How will insurance handle nerve repair in my case?

If the answer to the nerve question is no, it’s okay to ask why, and it’s okay to seek a second opinion. Our team has helped train more than 300 surgeons in this technique, so there are more places to find it than ever before.

Share This With Someone You Love

Hereditary risk runs in families, which means this conversation rarely belongs to just one person. If you have a sister, daughter, cousin or friend thinking about genetic testing or preventive surgery, sharing this may help them know what’s possible.

Every patient’s situation is different, and this article is not a substitute for personal medical advice. If you’d like to talk through your options, we’re here for you.

Striving to get you better than you’ve ever been. Schedule an in-person or virtual consultation.